Over
the last couple of days I've been in a "discussion" about the
Conservatives attacking Justin Trudeau for a comment he made regarding
the deeply serious situation in the Ukraine. The discussion group has a
policy of no "opposition bashing", because it is a group dedicated to
finding ways to unseat Stephen Harper. That's why I was there, in fact -
because to me Stephen Harper is the most frightening PM we have had in many years - he is a dictator. I've lived under a dictator once before in my lifetime.
I commented on that "discussion" that I thought Justin showed a lack of
judgment in his remark. So, before we go further, here's the remark in
its entirety:
"President Yanukovych has been made illegitimate.
It's very worrying, especially because Russia lost in hockey, they'll
be in a bad mood. We fear Russia's involvement in Ukraine," Trudeau
said.
"Just because of hockey?" asked Guy Lepage, the show's host.
"No. That's trying to bring a light view in a situation that's extremely serious," Trudeau said.
Now, in the context of talking about a devastating situation in which
many people were killed, he joked about the Russians being in a bad mood
after the hockey, and then comments that he is trying to bring a light
view in a serious situation. My opinion? He showed a distinct lack of
judgment in that remark - an opinion held by some of his fellow Liberals
- and *of course* the Conservatives are going to jump on that - he
handed it to them on a platter. Someone who aspires to be the Prime
Minister of the country needs to demonstrate a bit more wisdom and
judgment, in my opinion.
So here's the thing which makes me
smile - I was told that suggesting Trudeau made a stupid remark - and I
believe it was - was "opposition bashing". Hmmm - seems to me that as
soon as we are expected to be un-critical of the opposition, we're
being told we have to think alike - a kind of "if you aren't with us
you're against us" mentality. IF we are "rallying to unseat Harper" then
we also have to able to say that we think the opposition may have made
an error. Well, I've left that discussion, because clearly it wasn't a
discussion, it was an expectation that we will all see everything the
same way.
So here's my question: what's the difference between an honest exchange of opinions, and "bashing"?